Do I Need an Independent Examination for My Charity in the UK?

If you're a charity trustee or treasurer in England or Wales, you've probably come across the term independent examination — but you might not be entirely sure whether it applies to your charity, what it actually involves, or how it differs from an audit.

You're not alone. The rules can feel complex, especially if you're running a small or growing charity without a dedicated finance team. This guide cuts through the jargon and gives you a clear, plain-English answer to one of the most common questions we hear: do I actually need an independent examination?

If your charity is registered in England or Wales and your gross annual income is more than £25,000, you are currently required to have an independent examination. That threshold rises to £40,000 from the 1st October 2026

What Is a Charity Independent Examination?

An independent examination is a form of external financial scrutiny required by the Charity Commission for England and Wales. It's the lighter-touch alternative to a full statutory audit, designed specifically for small and medium-sized charities.

The examiner reviews your accounts to check that they appear correct, agree with the underlying financial records, and have been prepared in accordance with the relevant accounting standards. In technical terms, it provides negative assurance — the examiner confirms there is nothing that has come to their attention suggesting the accounts are wrong, rather than positively verifying every single transaction as an auditor would.

The process is governed by Charity Commission guidance CC31 (for trustees) and CC32 (for independent examiners), with the legal basis sitting within the Charities Act 2011.

Do I Need an Independent Examination for My Charity in the UK?

Whether your charity needs an independent examination depends primarily on your gross annual income. Here is how the rules currently work for charities registered in England and Wales.

Income of £25,000 or below

No external scrutiny is required. Trustees may choose to commission an independent examination voluntarily — for example if a funder requests it — but there is no legal obligation to do so.

Income between £25,001 and £250,000

An independent examination is required. This can be carried out by any suitably independent and knowledgeable person — it does not need to be a qualified accountant, though in practice most charities use one.

Income between £250,001 and £1,000,000

An independent examination is required, but the examiner must be a member of a recognised professional accountancy body — such as the ICAEW, ACCA, ICAS, CIPFA, or ICAI — or a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners (ACIE).

Income over £1,000,000 — or income over £250,000 with gross assets over £3.26 million

A full statutory audit is required. An independent examination is not sufficient at this level and only a qualified auditor may carry out the work.

The key takeaway: if your charity's gross income sits anywhere between £25,000 and £1 million, an independent examination is your legal obligation — not an optional extra.

Important — always check your governing document. Even if your income falls below the audit threshold, your charity's governing document, a major funder, or the Charity Commission itself may still require a full audit. Always check your constitution and any grant conditions before assuming an independent examination will suffice.

Independent Examination vs Audit: What's the Difference?

This is one of the most commonly asked questions around charity audit thresholds in the UK, so let's be clear on the distinction.

Independent Examination

The examiner checks that your accounts appear to be in order and are consistent with your financial records. They are not required to independently verify every transaction or dig into the systems and controls behind the numbers. It's a proportionate, cost-effective check — well-suited to the majority of UK charities.

Statutory Audit

An audit goes much deeper. The auditor provides positive assurance, verifying the underlying records, testing your financial controls, and confirming that the accounts give a true and fair view. It's significantly more involved, requires a qualified auditor, and comes at a higher cost. The Charity Audit Survey 2024 found the median cost of an audit for charities with income between £1–2 million was close to £10,000.

For most charities below the audit threshold, an independent examination strikes the right balance between accountability, transparency, and proportionality.

Who Can Carry Out a Charity Independent Examination?

The Charities Act 2011 requires trustees to appoint an independent person who is reasonably believed to have the requisite ability and practical experience to carry out a competent examination of the accounts.

For charities with income of £250,000 or less

The examiner must be independent of the charity and have sufficient knowledge of charity accounts and the Charities SORP. This does not need to be a qualified accountant, though most charities use one.

For charities with income between £250,001 and £1,000,000

The examiner must hold membership of one of the recognised accountancy bodies listed in the Charities Act 2011, or be a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners (ACIE). Eligible bodies include the ICAEW, ACCA, ICAS, CIPFA, and ICAI.

In all cases, the examiner must meet the following requirements:

• Be completely independent of the charity — they cannot be a trustee or employee
• Have no close personal or financial connection to the charity or its trustees
• Understand charity accounting principles and the Charities SORP
• For income over £250,000: hold a recognised professional qualification or ACIE Fellowship

“For most charities, an independent examination is the proportionate, cost-effective way to meet your legal obligations - without the time and expense of a full statutory audit”

Important: Threshold Changes Coming in October 2026

This is something every charity trustee in England and Wales needs to know about. The government has confirmed that new financial thresholds will come into force on 1 October 2026, following a public consultation and formal government response published in late 2025. Here is a summary of what is changing:

• Independent examination threshold rises from £25,000 to £40,000 annual income
• Qualified examiner threshold rises from £250,000 to £500,000 annual income
• Statutory audit threshold rises from £1,000,000 to £1,500,000 annual income
• Audit asset threshold rises from £3.26 million to £5 million, combined with the new £500,000 income test

The changes are designed to reduce unnecessary administrative burdens on smaller charities. Around 11,000 charities are expected to no longer need an independent examination under the new threshold, while roughly 9,000 more charities will be able to use a non-qualified examiner — generating estimated annual sector savings of over £30 million.

Planning ahead. Although the changes don't take effect until October 2026, it's worth reviewing your position now. If your charity's income sits between £25,000 and £40,000, you may no longer need an independent examination after that date. Trustees of growing charities approaching the new thresholds should also begin briefing on what the transition will mean for their reporting obligations.

What About Scotland and Northern Ireland?

It's important to note that the rules described in this guide apply to charities registered in England and Wales only, regulated by the Charity Commission for England and Wales.

If your charity is registered in Scotland, different requirements apply. Scottish charities must have an independent examination regardless of income level, with the threshold only determining the level of examiner required. The Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR) provides its own detailed guidance.

For charities in Northern Ireland, regulation falls under the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland (CCNI). There are currently no additional external scrutiny requirements for England and Wales-registered charities that also operate in Northern Ireland, but it is always worth checking if your charity is separately registered there.

What Does the Independent Examination Actually Involve?

Understanding what happens during an examination helps trustees prepare effectively and get the most from the process. A competent independent examiner will typically do the following:

• Review the annual accounts and trustees' annual report
• Compare the accounts to the underlying accounting records
• Check that the accounts comply with applicable accounting standards and the Charities SORP
• Look for any matters of material significance that may need reporting to the Charity Commission
• Consider whether the accounts are consistent with their knowledge of the charity
• Issue a signed independent examiner's report to accompany the accounts

The examiner has a statutory duty to report certain matters to the Charity Commission — such as evidence of fraud, serious mismanagement, or significant departures from the charity's objects. A good examiner will also highlight recommendations to trustees, even where no formal reporting duty arises.

A good independent examiner doesn't just tick a compliance box - they can add real value by highlighting risks, flagging concerns, and helping trustees understand their accounts more clearly

‍